Phoebe Palmer: Did You Know?

Reclaiming John

Methodist holiness advocates said their movement had started with John Wesley. They were just reminding Methodism of its founder’s teachings on entire sanctification or “perfect love"—the complete orientation of the heart toward God and away from sinning.

Camping out (in style) for Christ

During its post-Civil War “camp meeting phase,” the holiness revival spread quickly beyond Methodism’s bounds. In 1887, Presbyterian minister A. B. Simpson founded the non-Wesleyan Christian and Missionary Alliance (C&MA) on the teachings of Christ our Savior, Sanctifier, Healer (a common holiness theme by the 1890s), and Coming King. For many years, the C&MA held annual camp meetings at a former temperance campground in Old Orchard, Maine.

Hoofing it

The Methodist holiness folk were known for their traveling evangelists—male and female. One day, on the “gospel trail” with her organist Treena Platt, evangelist Mary Cagle’s pony became ill. Having heard that John Wesley had once prayed successfully for the healing of his horse, Cagle decided to do the same. “I don’t know how to pray for a horse,” Platt protested. “Pray just like you would for a person,” said Cagle; “we need her in the service of the Lord.” Cagle wrote in her autobiography that they “prayed through to victory” in the house and then went to the barn to find the horse already mending. (Contributed by Jennifer Woodruff Tait.)

Reaching the lowest of the low

Many holiness workers followed in the footsteps of Phoebe Palmer, bringing spiritual and physical help into such poverty-stricken and seemingly godforsaken places as the tenement described in an 1854 report of New York’s Five Points district: “Open that door—go in, if you can get in. There is no bed in the room—no chair—no table—no nothing—but rags, and dirt, and vermin, and degraded, rum-soaked human beings.”

Just do it.

Charles G. Finney and the Oberlin perfectionists (p. 22) were the earliest 19th-century non-Wesleyans who taught an attainable holiness. Hear the Gospel, exercise your will, and you could fulfill Jesus’ command: “Be ye perfect as your Father is perfect” (Matt. 5:48-. Oberlin perfectionists found the teachings of Phoebe Palmer and the Wesleyans ethically weak and sentimental.

Harriet before . . .

Uncle Tom’s Cabin author Harriet Beecher Stowe, no Wesleyan herself, echoed the yearning of thousands in the holiness movement: “I have often thought ‘Why am I thus restless? Why not at peace? I love God and Jesus and in general I mean to conform my life to Him.’ The more I groaned in spirit, and longed and prayed, the more inveterate and determined and unsubdued seemed every opposing desire.”

. . . and after

Stowe felt God answered her prayers: “Whereas once my heart ran with a strong current to the world, now it runs with a current the other way. The will of Christ seems to me the steady pulse of my being. I am calm, but full, and find I can do all things through Christ.”

The saints go marching out

In 1877, Methodist holiness preacher John P. Brooks denounced the “easy, indulgent, accommodating, mammonized” kind of Methodism that “erected gorgeous and costly temples to gratify its pride.” Brooks wrote The Divine Church, the textbook for the “come-outers” who left their churches to form new denominations.

The Pentecost connection

Many holiness “come-outers” moved right through their new denominations and into the Pentecostal movement (p. 25). William Seymour, the black preacher whose Azusa Street Revival (1906) birthed Pentecostalism, had been an evangelist with Daniel S. Warner’s “Evening Light Saints” (p. 33). After Azusa, some holiness churches moved wholesale into Pentecostalism.

Holiness “arrives”

The holiness campground at Ocean Grove, N.J., founded in 1869, became the most popular Christian resort on the East Coast. President Ulysses S. Grant was a frequent visitor. On August 25, 1899, William McKinley became the first president to speak in Ocean Grove’s 8,000-seat auditorium. He was followed by Presidents Theodore Roosevelt, William H. Taft, and Richard M. Nixon.

Bishops to zealots: “This is our doctrine”

In 1894 a group of Southern Methodist bishops wrote a letter sharply criticizing the Methodist holiness “party.” Methodism, they said, had never stopped being a holiness church. It needed no special agencies to press the point.

The town saint and the country saint

By 1885, the national holiness movement had two distinct wings: a rural, emotional, ethically strict wing inclined to throw off churchly structure and an urban, intellectual, less rigorous wing eager to work with the mainstream churches who shared their concern for a “higher Christian life.” The “come-outers” emerged from the first group.

The utmost holiness devotional classic

Oswald Chambers, author of My Utmost for His Highest, was a holiness advocate. Sanctified in 1901 after an intense religious crisis, Oswald went on to visit many holiness camp meetings and teach at holiness schools (p. 25).

Why I Like the Holiness People

by Rev. John B. Culpepper

I like their aim. They aim high. If they miss, nevertheless, they have scored one good point.

They are uncompromising.

They are against sin and wrong, including Sunday trains, secular newspapers, Sunday cooking, Sunday gossip, tobacco, and other uncleanness. 

They are Prohibitionists, almost to a man.

They are agitators.

They make and distribute tracts.

They circulate books. 

They have a catching sort of degree of spirituality.

They are in for everything that is good.

They say "amen" out loud.

They shout as I feel. They [root] for a fellow while he is preaching.

If the load is heavy, they all jump out and push.

Wherever you meet one, he is already organized and ready for work.

If they are scared, they pray and shout, and work and move, so that it can't be detected.

They always want to dig deeper, climb higher and know and do more.

They are long-winded in the closet, and nearly out of breath in a testimony service.

Every one of them will pray if you call on them, and if the fuse seems damp, they will pray, call or no call.

They are God's globe-trotters.

They don't ask how many are the enemy, but where are they?

They can shout in the cemetery.

They actually use the Bible in their work.

They will go to China or Africa as cheerfully as to the market.

It is not a money question with them.

They know the Holy Spirit.

They love you hard.

Their experience throws up a highway I'd like to die on.

They've come to stay.

They are unpopular with dirt, dignity, and the devil.

They are not in "ruts."

They cry and run as if they had jumped the fox. That makes me spur on in the chase.

Whenever I meet or hear one of them, it makes me want to quit something, or do something, or go somewhere, or be somebody.

They are my kinsfolk.

Holiness Advocate, Fayetteville, N.C., Aug. 15, 1903.

By Chris Armstrong

[Christian History originally published this article in Christian History Issue #82 in 2004]

Next articles

Phoebe Palmer: From the Editor

Phoebe Who?

Chris Armstrong

Living History

From fire on Mount Athos to Saxon king crosses.

Compiled by Ted Olsen and Chris Mosey


Did you know men slept on the Bridges?

Bramwell Booth

Christian History Timeline: The Holiness Movement

Chronology of the holiness movement 1824–1923

the Editors
Show more

Subscribe to magazine

Subscription to Christian History magazine is on a donation basis


Support us

Christian History Institute (CHI) is a non-profit Pennsylvania corporation founded in 1982. Your donations support the continuation of this ministry


Subscribe to daily emails

Containing today’s events, devotional, quote and stories