Fractures in Francis’s Order

“MAKE ME AN INSTRUMENT of your peace” may typify the Franciscan spirit, but Francis’s followers have sometimes been anything but peaceful. Fights broke out over how strictly and carefully to obey Francis’s commands. Controversies over the Later Rule and the Testament of Francis led to clashes, imprisonments, and even killings. The chart below captures the most important controversies and reform movements.

In spite of their volatile past, today the Franciscan orders accent what they hold in common.


• Later Rule approved in 1223.

• Francis writes his Testament before he dies in 1226. Already, many Franciscans, who live throughout Europe, have had no contact with Francis or his Rule.

• In 1230, Pope Gregory IX decrees that Francis’s Testament has no binding force on the Order. He also approves the right for the Order to use, though not own, property.

• After decades of ferment in the Order, in 1310, Ubertino da Casale calls for a return to the fundamentals of Francis’s Rule, especially strict poverty.

In 1317, his followers, the “Spirituals,” are excommunicated as heretics and arrested; some are burned.

Order of Friars Minor 


(O.F.M. Conv.) 

In 1430, friars residing in study centers and urban “convents” (hence their name) are permitted to own property and receive revenues.

In 1517, they are separated from the Observants. They live out a more settled expression of Francis’s ideals.

Order of Friars Minor 



In the 1330s, friars in south Assisi begin following a “stricter observance” of the Rule.

In 1415, they gain ecclesiastical recognition, and in 1443 are given their own Vicar General.

In 1517, they are separated from the Conventuals and tend to practice an itinerant ministry.

Order of Friars Minor 


(O.F.M. Cap.) 

In 1525, Observant Matteo da Basci seeks to live literally by Francis’s Rule.

Other Observants try to thwart the movement, so in 1529, da Basci’s followers, known as Capuchins, receive papal permission to become an independent order. They emphasize a contemplative way of life. CH

By the Editors

[Christian History originally published this article in Christian History Issue #42 in 1994]

Next articles

Controversial Passages

Three passages of Francis's rule led to bitter controversy.

Francis of Assisi: Christian History Interview — Modern Medieval Man

Eight hundred years later, Francis’s life and message seem remarkably up to date.

Conrad Harkins

Francis of Assisi: Recommended Resources

More resources about Francis, his order, and his times.

Conrad Harkins

Tattered Treasure of Assisi

How a rich and carefree man relinquished everything to follow Christ.

Lawrence S. Cunningham
Show more

Subscribe to magazine

Subscription to Christian History magazine is on a donation basis


Support us

Christian History Institute (CHI) is a non-profit Pennsylvania corporation founded in 1982. Your donations support the continuation of this ministry


Subscribe to daily emails

Containing today’s events, devotional, quote and stories